Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

Publications are grouped in terms of their age, discipline/field and publication type. A citation distribution for each group is formed by ordering publications based on their received citations. A mean value of citations is calculated for each distribution. Normalisation is based on the distibutions and mean values. The use of field-normalised indicators aims to allow for comparisons of publications accross disciplines. The sections below present these various field-normalised indicators.

Field-normalised

...

Top x% indicators

The field-normalised Top% Top x% indicators are based on the database’s field-specific citation distributions. The Top% Top x% indicators show the proportion of the analyzed publication set that belongs to the most frequently cited x percentile of the publications of the same field, publication year and publication type. Top% Top x% indicators are used as indicators of high citation impact. For example, Top10% Top 10% share and Top1% Top 1% share demonstrate the relative share of publications reaching both high (10%) and top (1%) impact within the publication set.

Top x% -

...

indices

The Top x% -index show the relative proportion of the analyzed publication set that belongs to the most frequently cited x percentile of the publications of the same field, publication year and publication type. For example, a Top 1% index value exceeding 1 means that more than 1% of the publications in the analysed publication set belong to the most cited 1% of the field of science in question.

...

Responsible use

The Top x% indicators seek to account for disciplinary differences regarding publication and citation practices as well as accounting for the publication date. They are not sensitive to individual publications with a high number of citations.

Remember that

  • Top% Top x% indicators only assign value to a small proportion of the publications, while others are ignored.
  • Drawing the limit at a certain percentile is arbitrary; instead of Top 1% and Top 10% we could just as well analyse the Top 5% and Top 15%.
  • The indicators are based on classifications of fields of science that are not entirely unproblematic (more information on this can be found in the chapter Classification of fields of science.
  • When reviewing the Top x% indicators of fairly recent publications (published less than five years ago), it should be noted that the citation numbers are low in certain fields of science. In such cases, a meaningful distribution for calculating the Top x% indicator does not yet exist. 
  • Different types of publications accumulate citations in different ways. A conference publication, for example, can become included in the Top x% publications with far fewer citations than a journal article.
  • See also the questions related to assessing responsibility in the chapter Indicators.

...

  • The indicators are based on mean values. Individual publications with a high number of citations can have a major impact on the indicator’s value. 
  • When reviewing fairly recent publications, it should be taken into account that the citation numbers are lower within certain fields, due to which small changes in the number of citations can lead to major changes in the indicator value.
  • The indicators are based on classifications of fields of science that are not entirely unproblematic (more information on this in chapter Classification of scientific fields of science.
  • See also the questions related to assessing responsibility in the chapter Indicators.

Normalised indicators in databases and other sources


Top x% indicesData source

Comments about the indicator

Link to method description
PP(
topx%
top x%)CWTS Leiden ranking


Indicators -The CWTS Leiden Ranking

top 10-indexState of scientific research in Finland


Bibliometrisiin analyyseihin liittyviä käsitteitä

 

(in Finnish only)

Top x% shares


% Documents in Top 1%
% Documents in Top 10%

InCites


View the InCites: Understanding the Metrics tab `Percentiles´
See also: Documents in Top 1% and 10%

Outputs in Top Citation Percentiles

SciVal

Non-field-normalized "Outputs in Top Citation Percentile" indicator is based on citations.

The field-normalized "Outputs in Top Citation Percentile" indicator is determined based on the publications' FWCI values. The citation window for FWCI values is the year of publication plus the following three full years.


View SciVal Metric: Outputs in Top Citation Percentiles

Yrjö Leino & Marianne

Gauffriaun

Gauffriau. Guest Post: Understanding SciVal’s calculation of field-weighted percentile indicators – The Bibliomagician 

SciVal also features the Outputs in Top Citation Percentiles -indicator , which is not normalised by the scientific field.

Top % publications


Highly cited papersEssential Science Indicators, 
Web of Science, InCites


Essential Science Indicators - Highly Cited Papers
Highly Cited Thresholds

Hot papers

Essential Science Indicators,
Web of Science, InCites.


Hot Paper Thresholds

Normalised citation indicators


Category Normalized Citation Impact (CNCI) 
InCites


InCites: Understanding the Metrics
See tab "Normalized"

Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI)
SciVal
Research Metrics Guidebook
Mean Normalized Citation Score (MNCS)
Leiden ranking
Indicators The CWTS Leiden Ranking
The Field Citation Ratio (FCR) Dimensions
What is the FCR?
Co-citation Percentile Rank (CPR)JYUcite
JYUcite: What is CPR?

...

H-index

One of the best known bibliometric indicators is the h-index, also known as Hirsch index. It was developed by Jorge E. Hirsch in 2005. Read more about the topic in the original article

...

Data sourceDescription
Web of Science

The h-index value is based on a list of publications ranked in descending order by the Times Cited count. An index of h means that there are h papers that have each been cited at least h times. Read more: Web of Science: h-index information

Scopus

A scientist has an index h if h of his/her Np papers has at least h citations each, and the other (Np h) papers have no more than h citations each. Read more:  The The Scopus h-index, what’s it all about?

Google Scholar

The h-index of a publication is the largest number h such that at least h articles in that publication were cited at least h times each. For example, a publication with five articles cited by, respectively, 17, 9, 6, 3, and 2, has the h-index of 3. Read more: Google Scholar metrics

...